Evaluating Marketing Options for Local Gym: Google Ads vs. Media Agency Services
As a small business owner or marketing manager for a local gym, determining the most effective way to boost online visibility can be challenging. Recently, I encountered a situation that highlights some common questions and concerns about Digital Marketing strategies, particularly regarding Google advertising and third-party media services. I’d like to share my insights and seek advice from the community on this topic.
The Context
Currently, I am responsible for both the marketing efforts and front desk operations at a neighborhood gym. Recently, my employer engaged a media company that promises to position our gym’s website among the top three Google search results for specific keywords. They requested a list of six keywords and three headlines, resembling the structure of Google Ads ad groups. However, what caught my attention was a particular claim from the media firm:
“Google front page unlimited clicks, each keyword limited to only two cooperating companies.”
This statement raises questions because, in my understanding of Google Ads, multiple advertisers can bid on the same keywords simultaneously. The claim suggests an exclusivity that seems inconsistent with standard auction-based search advertising, prompting me to question the legitimacy of their approach.
Key Questions and Considerations
Given this context, several important questions come to mind:
-
Is claiming “keyword exclusivity” a legitimate feature of Google Ads or any reputable digital advertising platform?
From my knowledge, Google’s auction system allows multiple advertisers to compete on the same keywords, so such exclusivity is atypical. Could this be a marketing ploy, or does some other platform offer such guarantees? -
If we directly set up a Google Ads campaign targeting the same keywords and budget, can we realistically expect top-three rankings?
While paid ads can secure prime positions, achieving consistently top-three SERP placements depends on factors like bid amounts, quality scores, and budget. Properly optimized campaigns often produce good results, but there are no absolute guarantees. -
What are the advantages and disadvantages of contracting a third-party media agency versus managing Google Ads campaigns internally for a small business?
External agencies may bring expertise and save time, but they also add costs, and sometimes make guarantees that are hard to verify. Managing in-house requires learning and effort but offers more control and transparency. -
Are there warning signs or red flags to watch for when dealing with third-party services claiming guaranteed search results?
Be cautious of
