Content Strategy: Rewrite, Noindex, or Delete?

Tackling Low-Quality Rewrite, Noindex, or Delete?

In the realm of content creation, maintaining high-quality standards can be a challenge, as we recently discovered. Over the past four years, a writer on our team produced around 1,000 articles that fall into the category of “average.” The consensus is clear: these articles are dragging down the overall quality of our site.

Mistakes happen, and while we can’t change the past, we can certainly adjust our course moving forward. Now, we’re faced with a decision akin to “Snog, Marry, Avoid,” but in the SEO world, it’s “Rewrite, Noindex, or Delete.”

Options on the Table

Rewriting such a large volume of articles seems like an impractical endeavor, especially since they aren’t contributing any organic traffic to the site.

Deleting these posts might feel too severe and could potentially lose any minimal value they might hold.

Noindexing them is an option, as it doesn’t remove them from the site, but it leaves us wondering if they’re still casting a shadow over our site’s overall quality.

What’s the Best Move?

We’re reaching out to gather thoughts and opinions. What would be the best course of action to enhance our site’s credibility and performance? Drop us your insights as we navigate this content conundrum!

Technical SEO

Hubsadmin

2 responses to “Content Strategy: Rewrite, Noindex, or Delete?”

Hubsadmin says:

February 28, 2025 at 9:43 am
Addressing the challenge of deciding what to do with 1,000 average articles is certainly a daunting task, but it’s essential to tackle it strategically to enhance your site’s overall quality and SEO performance. Here’s a practical approach that balances the options of rewriting, noindexing, or deleting:
1. Audit and Analyze: Begin with a comprehensive content audit. Tools like Google Analytics, Google Search Console, or any SEO tool can help identify which articles receive traffic, have backlinks, or hold potential for improvement. Focus on metrics such as page views, bounce rate, and engagement.
2. Prioritize Content Based on Value and Potential:
  - High Opportunity: Articles that have some organic traffic but need significant improvements. These could be rewritten or updated with fresh and relevant information, enhanced with better keywords, and optimized for user intent.
  - Low Potential: Articles that receive no traffic, lack backlinks, and don’t align with your current content strategy or brand voice. These should be candidates for noindexing or deletion.
3. Rewriting Strategy:
  - For articles identified as high opportunity, invest time rewriting them. Focus on enhancing quality by adding unique insights, actionable advice, multimedia elements, and updated SEO strategies to align with current trends and algorithms.
  - Consider merging similar topics to create comprehensive guides, which can reduce redundancy and improve user experience.
4. Noindex Strategically:
  - Use noindex for articles that hold some internal value but do not justify a public presence due to low quality or relevance. This way, they remain accessible for internal use or as supporting documents but do not dilute your site’s SEO performance.
  - Monitor these articles periodically. If they continue to have no internal value, consider further action.
5. Delete with Caution:
  - Remove content that is outdated, irrelevant, or potentially harmful to your brand reputation. Ensure you employ 301 redirects for any deleted article that might have valuable backlinks or direct users to a related, updated article.
  - Always maintain a backup before deleting to prevent any irreversible loss.
6. Continuous Improvement:
  - Establish a regular content audit routine to ensure ongoing quality and relevance.
  - Foster a content culture where quality over quantity is prioritized, perhaps by implementing more stringent editorial guidelines or investing in training for your writers.
This tiered approach allows you to maximize the potential of your existing content while ensuring that your site remains authoritative, relevant, and SEO-friendly. It’s
Reply
Hubsadmin says:

March 26, 2025 at 5:16 pm

This is an interesting dilemma that many content creators face! One strategy worth considering is conducting a thorough analysis of these 1,000 articles to identify any patterns or specific issues that categorize them as “average.” This could help inform your decision-making process. For instance, if certain topics seem to resonate more with your audience despite the articles’ lower quality, a targeted rewrite could provide value while also boosting engagement.

Regarding the three options, a mixed approach might be beneficial. For articles that have the potential for strong traffic with some editing, rewriting could breathe new life into them. Meanwhile, you might noindex content that has little to no organic interest but still offers some value, perhaps as part of an overarching informational resource on your site. Lastly, don’t forget about the potential of deleting pieces that are detrimental; if they’re unlikely to ever align with your current quality standards or brand, it might be best to remove them entirely.

Additionally, consider the long-term strategy: establishing clear guidelines and quality checks for future content can help mitigate these issues down the road. Regular audits of your content could also ensure that you maintain high standards without accumulating more low-quality material. Looking forward to seeing how this unfolds!

Reply