Is our SEO company ripping us off ? Should we switch to a different one?

Is Your SEO Agency Underperforming? A Marketing Manager’s Dilemma

Navigating the murky waters of Digital Marketing can be a challenge, especially when it comes to Search Engine Optimization (SEO). As a marketing manager for a roofing company, I’ve recently started to question the effectiveness of our current SEO agency, which has been managing our account since long before my arrival. After a deep dive into our website’s traffic data, I’ve uncovered some inconsistencies that merit a closer look.

Red Flags in Our Traffic Data

  1. Unexplained Traffic Surges
    One of the first issues that caught my attention was an unusual spike in organic and direct traffic—something that, on the surface, sounds good. However, these increases haven’t translated into more inquiries or leads. A glance at Google Search Console reveals a stark contrast; while Google Analytics shows a whopping 13,000 users from organic traffic in the last three months, Google Search Console indicates only 403 clicks. When you calculate that, it suggests that a mere 0.03% of our organic traffic is actually coming from Google. This discrepancy raises a ton of questions.

  2. Indexed Page Discrepancies
    Another puzzling concern surrounds the number of indexed pages. According to Google Search Console, we have 43 indexed pages. Yet, the agency reports boast over 400 pages that, they claim, are generating traffic and clicks. This includes some bizarre entries that have nothing to do with our business—like pages related to divorce law. It’s hard to accept that these irrelevant pages are providing any value to our roofing company.

  3. Pricey Services with Minimal Output
    For a monthly fee of $5,000, our agency produces just one blog post every quarter. Their pitch is that they use a proprietary AI tool that supposedly scans our site and those of our competitors to make optimizations. When I inquired about how we could rank for new keywords and index fresh pages without creating additional content, they insisted that their AI handles everything. They labeled traditional content creation as an “old school” approach, which left me skeptical.

Time for a Change?

Given these troubling findings, I’m left wondering whether it might be time to consider a switch to a different SEO agency. It’s crucial that we have a partner who not only provides transparent and effective services but also aligns with our business goals. If you find yourself in a similar situation, ask the tough questions and dig into the data. Your marketing strategy deserves nothing less than full accountability and optimum performance.

Stay tuned for more insights on navigating the complexities of seo and selecting the right partners for your business journey!

Hubsadmin

2 responses to “Is our SEO company ripping us off ? Should we switch to a different one?”

  1. It’s understandable to have concerns about your SEO company’s effectiveness, especially with the discrepancies you have noted. Let’s break down the issues you’ve raised and provide actionable insights.

    Analysis of Traffic Discrepancies

    1. Organic Traffic vs. Google Search Console Data:
    2. The stark contrast between the 13,000 users reported in Google Analytics and only 403 clicks indicated in Google Search Console (GSC) raises red flags. This discrepancy could mean a few things: tracking issues, bot traffic, or, sadly, inflated metrics from your SEO agency.

    3. Actionable Step: Use tools like Google Tag Manager to ensure that tracking codes are implemented correctly. Additionally, analyze your website’s traffic sources in detail. If possible, check server logs to identify the most common user agents accessing your site. This can help you understand whether you’re receiving exaggerated traffic figures potentially generated by bots.

    4. Indexed Pages vs. Reported Traffic:

    5. The difference in the number of indexed pages and the odd nature of those pages, particularly concerning unrelated topics (like law), implies that your SEO agency may be generating low-quality or irrelevant content to inflate their reports. This approach may not only waste resources but could also harm your site’s credibility and seo in the long term.
    6. Actionable Step: Verify the reported indexed pages by using GSC and ensure you are reviewing each page type. Because your business is specific to roofing, any traffic from unrelated topics will not convert into leads. An audit of the site’s relevant pages could illuminate areas needing improvement or highlight unnecessary or harmful content.

    Content Strategy Concerns

    1. Quality and Frequency of Content:
    2. Producing only one blog post per quarter is considerably low for effective seo, especially in a competitive market such as roofing. While the use of AI tools can aid in analysis and optimization, it shouldn’t replace the need for high-quality, original content that addresses customer needs, seo trends, and questions prospective customers might have.
    3. Actionable Step: Consider developing a content calendar that incorporates more frequent blog posts, case studies, or other forms of content that relate directly to your services, such as roof maintenance tips or seasonal guides. You can also explore the option of hiring freelance writers or using internal resources for content creation to improve output.

    Evaluating the Agency’s Value

    Lastly, the price you are paying ($5,000 a month) should correlate with tangible results, including lead generation and brand visibility. If you’re not seeing a return on investment, it’s worth having an open conversation with your agency about your concerns. Transparency is key in a successful partnership.

    Consider Your Options

    If after discussions you find that your SEO agency is unable to provide clear answers or satisfactory results, it might be time to consider a switch. Before making that leap:

    • Research Other Firms: Look for SEO agencies with proven track records specifically in your industry. Request case studies and references.
    • Set Clear KPIs: Define measurable objectives (e.g., organic traffic growth, lead generation) that you want your new SEO partner to achieve.
    • Conduct a Cold Analysis: If possible, obtain a second opinion. Engage a consultant to review your current strategy and suggest potential improvements or changes.

    In conclusion, trust your instincts. If something feels off and the data does not align with expected outcomes, it’s crucial to delve deeper. Whether you decide to stay with your current agency or move on, ensuring that your SEO efforts lead to measurable business growth is fundamental.

    Reply

  2. It sounds like you’ve done a thorough job analyzing your SEO situation, and it’s definitely concerning when the numbers just don’t add up. Your experience highlights a crucial aspect of Digital Marketing: transparency and accountability.

    When exploring potential SEO agencies, I recommend considering a few key factors:

    1. **Detailed Reporting**: Agencies should provide consistent and clear reports that align with multiple analytics platforms. It’s essential to know how they define “success” and how they track it beyond just surface metrics.

    2. **Content Strategy**: Instead of relying solely on AI tools, look for agencies that emphasize a holistic content strategy tailored to your audience. Quality and relevance should take precedence over quantity, and fresh, engaging content is vital for SEO longevity.

    3. **Audit and Benchmarking**: Before switching, consider conducting a comprehensive seo audit – an independent examination can provide clarity on your current performance and inform future decisions. It may also unearth potential improvements that your current agency has overlooked.

    4. **Client Reviews and Case Studies**: Researching other clients’ experiences can give you insight into the agency’s capabilities and ethics. Look for case studies similar to your industry to gauge how they’ve impacted other businesses.

    5. **Trial Period**: If you decide to pursue a new agency, see if they offer a short-term contract or trial period. This can mitigate risks and allow you to assess their effectiveness before committing long-term.

    Engaging in these discussions and decisions can be challenging, but prioritizing transparency

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Hubsadmin Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *